2-Smoke vs. 4-Stroke

by Yale Henry
(Beautiful British Columbia!)

I have read a lot of opinions about the two kinds of engines and being a motorcycle mechanic and an avid rider I of course have my own opinion.


2-strokes are lighter with less moving parts, although they lack low-end power. As soon as they gain rpm the power and torque just go up and up until you can barely hold on. The only maintenance issue with a 2-stroke is replacement rings and/or pistons, unless the person didn't mix the fuel right then there is a big problem. 2-strokes take more fuel sure, but with new technology coming out like DFI systems, 2-strokes will dominate 4-strokes in power and have a slightly higher fuel consumption.

4-strokes have a smoother powerband but, you beat the 2-stroke around the corner on the track but, OH WAIT!.. who's that passing you on the straight? The guy on the two stroke!

Many people think that maintenance is cheaper on a 4-stroke but the bill adds up over time. On avg. a 4-stroke will come in 4 or 5 times or more, for valve adjustments before the 2-stroke comes in for a ring or piston replacement. But eventually the 4-strokes rings have to be replaced, the valves and valve springs, timing chain replacement, it just gets more and more expensive whereas the 2-stroke has what?.. just rings and piston replacements. Do the math.

4-strokes have good low end power and a smooth powerband, so they are good for tricks, smooth riding and cornering.

2-strokes have excellent high rpm power, keep the rpm high and you have all the power you need in any situation, cornering, acceleration etc...

Btw, when a 4-stroke is poorly maintained or the rpm is too high for too long, the cost for repairs goes through the roof! They take longer to repair and they are harder to fix, so labor costs go up. Basically it would just be easier to buy a brand new 2-stroke which is a fraction of the cost for new parts and engine rebuilds.

Comments for 2-Smoke vs. 4-Stroke

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Sep 27, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
2 Stroke Injection
by: Coen

Did you know that Yamaha has 2-stroke engines with
EFI on Racing boats?

They don't want us to keep our hard earned money in our pockets and stop making the best dirt bikes
on the planet. AMA and FIM are to blame because they dont let the 2-strokes compete on equal terms! By this they talk about professionalism and are killing the sport.

Again: Sorry for my bad English.

Greetings from Holland

Sep 16, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Also..
by: Yale Henry

I forgot to add the fact you need to replace the bearings for the crank and connection rod which of course you have to do as well on a 4-stroke but, does this raise the price much? Well the 4-stroke has more bearings than the 2-stroke so it costs more for each replacement on labor and parts.. which also means buy a 2-stroke, save some money and gain riding time!

Sep 16, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Direct Injection Please!
by: Anonymous

Amen! I am hoping someone like KTM will come out with direct injection for the 2 stroke. That will keep the EPA happy, and maybe reduce fuel consumption? Bring it on!

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to 2 stroke vs 4 stroke.


Get The Basics RIGHT! And Watch Your Bike Skills & Enjoyment Increase. Over 800 Copies Purchased & Growing.. The Dirt Bike Garage Manual





Site Search